With his third release, Nine Inch Nails' Trent Reznor discusses commercial success and
keeping his music pure
By Rob Hooper, University Times, California State University, Los Angeles
Trent Reznor sits in the corner of a hotel bar and slowly sips an iced tea. He seems at ease
for someone who is homeless at the moment.
"I think I've moved every six months for the last 10 years," he says. His last residence in
Beverly Hills, the infamous site of the Sharon Tate slayings, was recently demolished by
"I have a certain degree of newfound maturity," he continues, "and it makes me desire
some kind of permanence like having a home. But now I'm faced with getting on a tour
bus for at least a year. And as great as that can be, it's ultimately a rather shallow
Shallow is not a term many people would associate with Reznor or his music, a project he
calls Nine Inch Nails (NIN). More of a solo venture than a group effort, NIN enables
Reznor to vocalize the sense of displacement he feels in his own life. The result is as
disturbing as it is provocative.
"I've never written an outright happy song," the 28-year-old admits. "If I did, then I doubt
it would fit into the context of a NIN record. And I don't really feel inspired to write about
happy s**t anyway. When I'm happy, the last thing I feel like doing is torturing myself
with my notebook in hand."
Reznor's anger and tortured-artist image attracted a cult following after he signed with
TVT Records in 1988. When his debut album, Pretty Hate Machine, was released the
following year, the popularity of NIN began to rise so rapidly that Reznor says he found it
"It was cool to see that record do well on its own merit because MTV and commercial
radio didn't embrace it until later," he says. "But at the same time, it was really weird
going from being a fanzine level band to outselling Jane's Addiction in merchandise sales
"The bigger the stakes, the more uncomfortable and out of control it starts to feel. It's cool
to be the underdog, but when you start rising to the top, there's more people ready to drag
you down any way they can."
Reznor is speaking of his relationship with TVT Records and its owner, Steve Gottlieb,
who paid little attention to NIN until sales from Pretty Hate Machine began to skyrocket.
A battle ensued over rights to NIN's next album, with Interscope Records finally stepping
in to release the 1992 EP Broken.
"It came down to a simple thing," Reznor says of the struggle that almost ended his
career. "What I'm most concerned about is that the record you get in the store and the way
you perceive NIN is the way I want it to be perceived. I don't want it to be diluted by
some marketing plan that's completely inappropriate and would make the music impure."
His frustration with the music industry provides the prevailing theme on Broken. The
six-song collection, which was recorded without TVT's knowledge, also showcases
Reznor's new-found interest in making his music as abrasive as possible. Less
dance-based than Pretty Hate Machine, the EP sounds more like a guitar-oriented wall of
Ironically, Reznor received a Grammy award last year for the track "Wish," an honor he's
quick to dismiss as meaningless.
"The best thing about it," he quips, "was that it's the only song to ever win a Grammy that
says 'fist f**k' in the lyrics."
Sarcasm aside, Reznor says he's come to terms with his hatred of the music industry.
Most of his energy for the past two years has gone into making the recently released
14-track opus The Downward Spiral (Nothing/TVT/Interscope). It's a project that he says
turned him into a workaholic.
"This album literally sucked the life out of me," he says. "I found it a difficult process...
because when I went into the studio, I knew that I didn't want to make Broken again. I
saw that as a trap I could easily fall into. When I write music, not everything comes out
really hard and mean like those songs.
"On the same token, I didn't want to go about making Pretty Hate Machine over again. So
I tried to experiment with different forms of intensity rather than just use loud guitars and
drums. Ten hard, fast songs don't have nearly the intensity of spacing the different
emotions out along the entire album."
While The Downward Spiral does contain some obvious musical mood swings, it also
gives Reznor a chance to express some of his political concerns. "Big Man With a Gun"
addresses misogynist attitudes in gangsta rap, whereas "Heresy" blends themes of sex and
"I was trying to explore some of the paranoia I have as a sexually active person in the age
of AIDS," he says of "Heresy."
"I guess I feel cheated for not growing up in a more liberated era. At the same time, what
gets me mad is the way the right wing has used the 'convenience' of this epidemic in
helping to promote their own agenda."
Reznor admits the issues brought up on the album may not exactly be Top 40 radio
material. "The first people who heard it outside my immediate camp thought the album
was commercial suicide," he says. "I'm not doing music to make millions of dollars,
though. Every record I've put out I thought was risky at the time.
"My main goal was to broaden the scope of NIN a little bit. I'm tired of trying to
second-guess what other people are going to like. It may not be the most obvious career
move for me, but if you give the album a chance, it may produce something for you that
you didn't expect."
The most unexpected element of The Downward Spiral is on the final track, "Hurt."
Although Reznor usually revels in his nihilism, the song's ending conveys a surprising
amount of optimism.
"I questioned whether or not to put that on there," he says.
When reminded that the music overpowers the vocals so that his lyrics are almost
indecipherable, Reznor smiles.
"I do that sometimes," he says. "When I'm scared, I just turn the vocals down."